A short, possibly spurious Socratic dialogue in which a young man begging for a teacher of political wisdom is steered instead toward Socrates' mysterious 'divine sign.'
Theages is a brief dialogue, often bracketed by scholars as inauthentic or of doubtful Platonic authorship, but transmitted in the ancient collections of Plato's works. It opens with Demodocus asking Socrates, privately, for advice: his son Theages is desperate to study with a sophist so he can learn how to govern people, and Demodocus does not know whether to indulge him. Socrates draws Theages into conversation and, through a series of questions, exposes that what the boy actually wants is not ordinary politics but the knowledge that would let him rule people against their will if necessary -- in effect, tyranny -- though Theages insists he wants only the willing rule that statesmen like Themistocles, Pericles, and Cimon enjoyed.
Socrates argues that this kind of political skill cannot simply be taught by professional sophists, and that even the great statesmen could not reliably pass their own skill on to their sons. He offers himself instead, but with a peculiar disclaimer: whatever benefit people have gotten from associating with him has not come through any teaching he consciously provides, but through a 'divine sign' (daimonion) that sometimes helps his companions and sometimes does not, unpredictably. He illustrates this with cautionary anecdotes: Timarchus ignored the sign and went to his death; Aristides, son of Lysimachus, flourished while near Socrates but lost his gains once away from him.
The dialogue matters less for airtight argument than for what it shows about how the historical Socrates was remembered and mythologized shortly after his death -- as a figure whose influence on the young was treated as quasi-oracular rather than as ordinary instruction. It is a useful test case for the boundary between Socrates the teacher of reasoned inquiry (as in Plato's major dialogues) and Socrates the object of semi-religious anecdote, and it directly engages the ambition, common among young Athenian aristocrats, to acquire political power through paid instruction from sophists.
“Socrates, I wanted to have a word with you privately, if you have the time. And even if you're rather busy, do make time for me anyway.”
— Theages · read this chapter →
“I suppose I'd wish to be a tyrant—over all mankind if possible, or as many as possible if not.”
— Theages · read this chapter →
“'Clitomachus,' he said, 'I am going now to my death, because I refused to obey Socrates.'”
— Theages · read this chapter →
“Well, Socrates, here's what I think we should do — let's spend time together and put this divine sign of yours to the test.”
— Theages · read this chapter →
It is a short dialogue about a young Athenian, Theages, who wants a teacher who can give him political power, and his father Demodocus, who asks Socrates for advice. Socrates draws out that Theages really wants power to rule people whether they consent or not, then offers himself as a companion, though he warns that any benefit comes from an unpredictable 'divine sign,' not deliberate instruction.
Many modern scholars doubt its authenticity and consider it likely written by a later member of Plato's school rather than Plato himself, though it circulated in the ancient manuscript tradition as a Platonic work.
It is a mysterious, unpredictable influence Socrates says accompanies him and sometimes helps the people he spends time with -- and sometimes does not -- rather than any deliberate teaching he provides. He tells Theages that Timarchus died after ignoring the sign, while Aristides made great progress while near Socrates but lost it once he left.
Demodocus is an Athenian father worried about his son's ambitions; Theages is his son, who wants to study under a sophist so he can learn to command and rule people, and who is ultimately steered toward Socrates instead.
Socrates names Prodicus of Ceos, Gorgias of Leontini, and Polus of Acragas as famous paid teachers who travel from city to city instructing wealthy young men, in contrast to Athenian statesmen who would mentor a young man for free.
Alcibiades 1 · Alcibiades 2 · Apology · Charmides · Cleitophon · Cratylus · Critias · Crito · Epinomis · Euthydemus · Euthyphro · Gorgias